Preventing Fuel Theft and Fuel Card Misuse with GPS Tracking
Fuel is one of the largest line items in any fleet budget. Industry commentary often puts it at roughly a quarter of operating costs for trucking carriers. A recent supplier study pegs it even higher for Canadian fleets, at about 35% of fleet spend. That makes fuel an attractive target, and the losses are often hard to see.
Fuel theft rarely looks like theft on a monthly statement. It looks like a bad week, a long route, or a price spike. This post covers where fuel losses come from, why they’re so easy to miss, and how GPS tracking helps Canadian fleets find and prevent them.
How Big is the Problem?
- In a 2024 survey, more than half of fleets suspected fuel fraud had occurred, and 55% of those said they lacked the evidence to prove it.
- Operations leaders surveyed in a WEX-backed study estimated that 19% to 22% of fleet spend is lost to theft and fraud. This covers more than fuel, and it’s an estimate, not an audit.
- In a Shell-reported finding, misuse accounts for roughly 80% of fuel-related incidents. That suggests the larger problem is often internal and ordinary rather than organized crime.
- Shell’s Fraud Matters report found that more than 86% of fleet managers believe fraud is occurring in their fleets.
Even the lower estimates add up. A fleet spending $20,000 a month on fuel that loses 5% to theft and misuse is losing $12,000 a year.
Where Fuel Losses Come From
Fuel losses generally fall into two groups: internal misuse and external fraud.
Internal Misuse and Theft
- Filling personal vehicles, family members’ vehicles, or portable containers on the company card
- Sharing cards or PINs between drivers (“buddy fueling”)
- Buying non-fuel items such as snacks, tools, or car washes
- Fuelling a vehicle that isn’t the one assigned to the card
- Padding fuel logs or reporting inflated purchases
- Siphoning fuel from parked vehicles or yard tanks
External Fraud
- Card skimming and cloning
- Compromised card data used far from where the fleet operates
Canadian carriers are seeing this. Peel Regional Police have investigated cases in Ontario where suspects allegedly cloned legitimate fleet fuel cards and sold discounted diesel to drivers at a Mississauga fuel station, with the charges billed to the fleets whose cards had been compromised. Truck News also reported Quebec carriers finding diesel purchases in states where none of their trucks had been.
The same coverage noted that some of the costliest losses come from basic gaps in card management. Examples include former employees keeping active cards, PINs written on the back of cards, and cards with no limits.
Why Fuel Losses are so Hard to Spot
Most fleets are looking at the wrong data. A fuel card statement tells you that a purchase happened, but not whether it made sense. Invoices show dollars and litres. They don’t show where the vehicle was, whether it was moving, or whether the fuel actually went into the right tank.
Prices complicate things further. When diesel jumps, a bigger fuel bill looks normal. In October 2026, CTV News reported Canadian diesel climbing from about $1.86 per litre in June to roughly $2.65, alongside a series of unusual fuel thefts under police investigation in Alberta. Police hadn’t linked the thefts to price, but higher prices raise the stakes for every litre that goes missing.

How GPS Tracking Helps Prevent Fuel Theft and Misuse
GPS tracking gives you an independent record of where each vehicle was and when. That lets you check a fuel purchase against reality instead of taking the card transaction at face value.
1. Verify Every Purchase Against Vehicle Location
This is the simplest check and often the most valuable. If a card is swiped at a station and the assigned vehicle was 80 km away, something is wrong. Whether the cause is a skimmed card, a shared card, or a driver filling someone else’s vehicle, location data exposes it.
2. Spot After-Hours and Off-Route Fuelling
Purchases at 2 a.m. on a Sunday, or at a station nowhere near the route, are classic red flags. GPS trip history and stop reports show whether the vehicle was where it should have been, and whether it was on duty at all.
3. Catch Idling and Unauthorized Use
Not every fuel loss is theft in the strict sense. Excess idling, personal trips in company vehicles, and detours burn fuel quietly. Tracking vehicle use after hours and on weekends shows how much of your fuel bill is paying for activity that has nothing to do with the job.
4. Detect Siphoning and Unexplained Fuel Drops
Where tank-level data is available, a sudden drop while the vehicle is parked is a strong signal of siphoning. Even without it, comparing distance driven to fuel purchased over time shows vehicles that consume far more than their peers.
5. Compare Vehicles and Drivers on a Like-for-Like Basis
When you know each vehicle’s kilometres and engine hours, fuel economy becomes measurable. A vehicle that suddenly uses 20% more fuel than similar units on similar routes is worth a look, whether the cause is mechanical, behavioural, or something worse.
6. Build an Evidence Trail
The Coast survey above is a reminder that suspicion isn’t enough. GPS records give you timestamped, objective data to support a conversation with a driver, a dispute with a card provider, or a police report. Evidence also acts as a deterrent: drivers behave differently when purchases can be checked.
GPS works best as part of a layered approach
No single tool stops every kind of fuel loss. The strongest programs combine GPS verification with sound card controls:
- Use card-level controls. Set purchase limits, restrict cards to fuel only, and limit daily transactions. WEX, for example, suggests capping daily transactions, restricting approved merchants, applying time-of-day controls, and regularly disabling unused cards.
- Assign cards and PINs to vehicles or drivers, and never share them. Cancel cards immediately when someone leaves.
- Review transactions weekly, not monthly. Early detection is the difference between a small loss and a large one.
- Know your card provider’s fraud policy. Some suppliers reimburse fraudulent transactions only if they’re reported within a set time, and may hold the customer responsible when valid card credentials were used. Ask before you sign.
- Reconcile fuel receipts with vehicle data. Compare litres purchased with tank capacity, distance driven, and the vehicle’s usual consumption.
- Set a clear fuel policy and have drivers sign it. People are more careful when expectations are written down.

A Practical Starting Point
- Establish a baseline. Pull three to six months of fuel card data and compare it with GPS distance and engine-hour data for each vehicle.
- Flag the outliers. Look for purchases that exceed tank capacity, happen after hours, occur far from the vehicle’s location, or repeat in quick succession.
- Tighten card controls. Clean up inactive cards, set limits, and remove shared PINs.
- Communicate openly. Tell drivers what’s being monitored and why.
- Review regularly. Make exception reports a routine part of fleet management, not a one-time audit.
A Note on Privacy and Trust
GPS tracking in company vehicles is a management tool, and it works best when employees know about it. Put your tracking and fuel card policies in writing and explain what data is collected and how it’s used. Privacy rules vary by province and by how vehicles are used, including personal use, so check your obligations with an employment or privacy professional. Most honest drivers welcome a system that protects them from false suspicion.
The Bottom Line
Fuel theft and fuel card misuse rarely announce themselves. They show up as slow, hard-to-explain increases in cost. GPS tracking lets you check what the fuel card says against what the vehicle actually did, so you can stop leaks early, document what you find, and discourage misuse.
If you’d like to see how location and usage data can bring more visibility to your fuel spend, contact GPS Tracking Canada for a consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does GPS tracking help prevent fuel theft?
GPS tracking records where each vehicle is, when it moves, and when it stops. By comparing that record with fuel purchases, you can see whether a fill-up happened where and when the vehicle was actually present. Purchases that don’t match are flagged for review, and drivers who know this is checked are far less likely to try.
What is fuel card misuse?
Fuel card misuse is any use of a company fuel card that falls outside your policy. Common examples include filling personal or family vehicles, buying non-fuel items, sharing cards or PINs between drivers, and fuelling a vehicle other than the one assigned to the card. Much of it is done by employees rather than outside criminals.
Can GPS tracking detect fuel card fraud?
GPS tracking can reveal many forms of fuel card fraud by showing whether the assigned vehicle was at the station when the card was used. If a transaction posts in one town while the vehicle was in another, the card may have been cloned, shared, or used for a different vehicle. It works best alongside card controls and regular transaction review.
What are the most common types of fuel theft in fleets?
The most common types include using company cards for personal vehicles or containers, sharing cards and PINs, buying non-fuel items, siphoning fuel from parked vehicles or yard tanks, and falsifying fuel logs. External fraud such as card skimming and cloning is also a growing concern.
How much money do fleets lose to fuel theft and fraud?
Estimates vary widely because much of it goes undetected. Industry surveys commonly suggest several percent of fuel spend at the low end, and higher figures when all theft, fraud, and unauthorized use are counted. Even a small percentage adds up quickly when fuel is one of your largest operating costs.
How can I tell if a driver is using a fuel card for personal vehicles?
Look for warning signs such as purchases that exceed the vehicle’s tank capacity, fill-ups outside work hours, fuelling at stations away from the vehicle’s route, or repeated fills close together. GPS records let you confirm whether the assigned vehicle was actually at the pump. If it wasn’t, you have clear grounds for a follow-up.
Can GPS tracking detect fuel siphoning?
It can help. If your system captures fuel level data, a sudden drop while a vehicle is parked is a strong sign of siphoning. Without tank-level data, you can still compare fuel purchased to distance driven and engine hours, and look for vehicles that use much more fuel than similar units on similar routes.
What is buddy fuelling, and how can I stop it?
Buddy fuelling is when drivers share a card or PIN so that one person pays for another’s fuel, whether for a company vehicle or a personal one. To stop it, assign cards and PINs to individual drivers or vehicles, prohibit sharing in writing, and compare card activity with GPS location to confirm the right vehicle was present.
What should I do if I find a suspicious fuel transaction?
Act quickly. Document the transaction and compare it with GPS data for that time and place. If the card may be compromised, contact your provider right away and ask about suspending the card. Some providers only reimburse fraud reported within a set period. For internal misuse, follow your written policy and consult HR or legal advice before taking action.
Is GPS tracking enough to stop fuel card fraud on its own?
No. GPS tracking is a powerful verification tool, but the best results come from layered controls. Combine it with card limits, individual PINs, prompt cancellation of unused cards, merchant and time-of-day restrictions, regular transaction reviews, and a clear written fuel policy.
What fuel card controls should I set up alongside GPS tracking?
Useful controls include per-transaction and daily limits, fuel-only restrictions, approved merchant lists, time-of-day and location rules, and individual PINs. Cancel cards immediately when employees leave, and review online account activity regularly. Many card providers offer these settings and some provide real-time alerts.
Can GPS tracking help with fuel waste, not just theft?
Yes. Not all fuel loss is theft. Excess idling, personal use of vehicles, unauthorized trips, inefficient routes, and aggressive driving all burn extra fuel. GPS reports on idling, stops, speed, and after-hours use show where fuel is being wasted so you can address it.
How quickly can I spot fuel theft with GPS tracking?
That depends on how often you review your data. With regular reports or alerts, suspicious activity can be spotted within days rather than discovered on a monthly statement weeks later. The sooner you catch it, the smaller the loss and the easier it is to resolve with the driver or card provider.
Does GPS tracking work for small fleets?
Yes. Small fleets often feel fuel losses most, because there’s less room in the budget to absorb them. Even a handful of vehicles can benefit from verifying fuel purchases against location and usage. It also gives owners visibility without having to review every receipt by hand.
Can I use GPS data as evidence if I suspect a driver of fuel theft?
GPS records are timestamped and objective, which makes them useful for documenting a concern and supporting a conversation with an employee, a card provider, or the police. How the data can be used in disciplinary or legal matters depends on your policies and local law, so speak with an employment lawyer or HR professional before acting.
Do I need to tell employees that vehicles are being tracked?
It’s best practice, and in many situations a legal expectation, to be open about tracking. Put your policy in writing, explain what data is collected and how it’s used, and have employees acknowledge it. Privacy requirements vary by province and by whether vehicles are used for personal purposes, so consult a privacy or employment professional.
Will drivers push back on GPS tracking?
Some may at first, especially if it’s introduced without explanation. Most concerns ease when you’re transparent about the purpose. Explain that tracking protects the company from fraud, protects honest drivers from false suspicion, and supports safety and efficiency. Tie it to a clear policy and apply it fairly.
What else can GPS tracking do besides preventing fuel theft?
Beyond fuel, GPS tracking supports dispatching and route planning, improves customer arrival estimates, reduces unauthorized vehicle use, helps recover stolen vehicles, supports driver safety coaching, and gives you records for maintenance scheduling and compliance. Fuel savings are often just one part of the return.
